SYMPOSIUM ON NEW MOTION PICTURE APPARATUS

A WIDE-RANGE STUDIO SPOT LAMP FOR USE WITH 2000-WATT FILAMENT GLOBES*

E. C. RICHARDSON**

 
 

During the Spring Convention at Hollywood, Calif., May 20-24, 1935, a symposium on new motion picture apparatus was held, in which various manufacturers of equipment described and demonstrated their new products and developments. Some of this equipment is described in the following pages; the remainder will be published in subsequent issues of the Journal.

In the motion picture studios there are a number of lamps that may be classified under the general term of "spot lamp." For the purpose of this paper, this classification may be divided into two groups, i. e., the condenser type and the reflector type. The condenser type embodies a source of illumination, the light from which is collected by means of a single condensing lens, usually of the planoconvex form, and means are provided for focusing the light-source in relation to the lens in order to vary the divergence of the projected beam. The ratings of these lamps range from 250 to 2000 watts, utilizing filament globes; and, in carbon arc equipment, from 35 to 115 amperes.
In the group of lamps designated as the reflector type will be found the lamps embodying light-sources in combination with glass or metal reflectors, usually of the paraboloid form. It is the present practice of the motion picture studios to use lamps of the reflector type provided with incandescent globes, with reflectors ranging in diameter from 18 to 36 inches. Carbon arc equipment of the reflector type includes the Sun arcs, the majority of which have reflectors 24 or 36 inches in diameter, although one major studio employs several Sun arcs using 60-inch reflectors.
The characteristic common to both the previously mentioned groups is that they may be used to project a beam of light, the divergence of which may be varied from a narrow angle, for the "spot," to an angle sufficiently wide to "flood" a considerable area. By altering the angle of divergence of the projected lightbeam, the area covered by the beam and the intensity within the beam may be increased or decreased according to requirements.
In attempting to improve any product three considerations come to one's attention: first, the incapacity of the existing product to meet the demands imposed upon it; second, the extension of the usefulness of the product into new fields of use; and, third, increasing the efficiency of the product itself.

FIG. 1. MR Type 210, Junior Solarspot.
The lamp under consideration in this paper-the MR Type 210 junior Solarspot, shown in Fig. 1-has been designed to function primarily as a spot lamp for use in photographing motion pictures. It is not an adaptation of equipment used in another field of illumination, but embodies in its design characteristics for overcoming the inability of existing equipment to fulfill the demands imposed upon it and provides a control of the lightbeam that widens the utility of the lamp as a tool of the cinematographer. The advantages achieved in this design have been largely effected by more efficiently utilizing the light from the 2000-watt G48 C13 bipost type of filament globe used in this equipment as the light-source.
Spot lamps of the condenser type have the advantage of good control over the projected beam. Using a 2000-watt lamp as the source, the beam can be converged to an angle of 8 degrees and flooded out to an angle as great as 45 degrees, although at such wide divergence the intensity of illumination is low. The disadvantage of spot lamps using the tungsten filament globes is their inefficient utilization of the light.
The power radiated by the 2000-watt globe is nearly 3 hp., a considerable portion of which is radiated at wavelengths lying below the visible range. That is to say, in other words, that the 2000-watt lamp radiates a lot of heat.

FIG. 2. Construction of typical 2000-watt condenser type studio spot.

The amount of heat radiated is such that even though plano-convex lenses are made of heat-resisting glass, their size in practical application, and to prevent excessive breakage, seems to be limited to a diameter of 8 inches and a focal length of 15 inches.


FIG. 3. Intensity distribution of condenser type spot lamp, with 8-inch diameter, 15-inch focus condenser; source: 120-volt, 2000-watt, G-48 bipost incandescent lamp.

Fig. 2 illustrates the layout of a typical 2000-watt condenser type studio spot. Behind the globe is a spherical mirror which is used to collect the light that would otherwise be unprojected and to reflect it so as to form an image between the coils of the filament grid. Tests reveal

FIG. 4. Reflector type of lamp equipped with parabolic mirror, showing angles of collection for spot and flood positions.

that when such a mirror is used in the combination shown in Fig. 2, good adjustment will increase the intensity of the beam by approximately 60-75 per cent above that afforded by a globe without such a reflector. With a beam divergence of 8 degrees in the spot lamp illustrated, it is possible to effect such a collection of direct and reflected light upon the condenser lens of only 32 degrees. When such a combination is used for flooding, with a beam divergence of 45 degrees, the angle of the collected light is increased to 71 degrees, but the intensity of the beam is so low that it is not of great photographic use. Fig. 3 shows the angular distribution of candle-power from a 2000-watt studio spot for beam divergences of 8, 18, 30, and 44 degrees.
The inherent fault of the condenser type of spot lamp for use with high-wattage globes is its incapacity to collect a large proportion of the light emitted by the source. Short-focus, wide-aperture condenser lenses would correct the difficulty; but for the plano-convex type of condenser, lenses of suitable focal length would be so thick as to cause great losses in transmission, and the breakage hazard, which is now rather objectionable, would be greatly increased due to the thickness of the lenses.

FIG. 5. Intensity distribution of reflector type of spot lamp, with 18-inch parabolic reflector and spill ring; source: 120-volt, 2000-watt, G48 bipost incandescent lamp.

The reflector types of lamp have the advantage over the previously described condenser spot lamps of collecting from the source a larger angle of light. A schematic drawing of a lamp equipped with a parabolic mirror 18 inches in diameter and having a focal length of 7 7/8 inches is shown in Fig. 4. The layout shows the lamp adjusted for a narrower beam of 8 degrees, in which case light within an

angle of 121 degrees is collected from the bulb. The dotted lines show the position when the light is flooded to an angle of 24 degrees, in which case the angle of collection of the mirror is 116 degrees. All the light from the front of the globe is lost, since, with the super-speed film in present use, it is necessary to apply spill rings to prevent any unprojected light from falling upon the set that may cause overexposure. This optical combination is most effective for narrow beam divergences in the lamps using 2000-watt, G48 C13 globes as the source.
Lamps of this type will spot down to a divergence of 8 degrees without projecting filament images that are seriously objectionable.

FIG. 6. Showing angles of collection of light in the 18-inch Sunspot lamp equipped with mirror.

FIG. 7. Intensity distribution of reflector type of spot lamp with 18-inch aplanatic metal reflector and spill ring; source: 120-volt, 2000-watt, C13 bipost incandescent lamp.

When such narrow divergences are required, lamps of this type are most effective; but the effectiveness is lost when they are flooded due to the characteristics of the parabolic reflectors. When the source is placed inside the focus of the reflector the intensity at and near the center of the beam drops much more rapidly than at the edges of the beam. This condition begins as soon as the globe is moved in from the focal point, and becomes more and more pronounced as the divergence increases; until, when the divergence is great enough, the projected light forms a "doughnut," which has no illuminating value in motion picture photography. Diffusing mediums can correct the bad distribution somewhat, but at the expense of much loss of illumination. Fig. 5 shows the intensity distribution of this type of equipment for divergences of 8, 16, and 20 degrees.
To overcome this fault of the parabolic mirror when used for projecting other than narrow beams, there are in use in the motion picture industry stamped metal mirrors, the curvature of which is primarily parabolic, but having a plurality of facets.


FIG. 8. MR 210 Junior Solarspot lamp, equipped
with concentric plano-convex Fresnel lens.

This type of mirror design injects an element of diffusion which improves the distribution of intensity in the projected beam. Fig. 6 shows an 18 inch Sun spot in which such a mirror is installed, and the angle of collection of the light. For the 14-degree divergence the angle of collection is 130 degrees, and for the 24-degree flood position it is 124 degrees. While mirrors of this design may be constructed from a number of small pieces of glass, a form of reflector frequently used in Europe, such construction is not, in our opinion, satisfactory. The amount of handwork involved in producing such a reflector in our country. Would make its cost prohibitive. Such reflectors have always tended to deteriorate rapidly, the silver peeling at the edges of the facets. The faceted metal mirrors used in the Hollywood studios are finished to a high degree, and are chromium plated. Their reflectivity is, of course, limited by the reflectivity of the chromium-plated surface. Their particular virtue is the smoothness of distribution, for divergences from 14 to 24 degrees. The angular distribution of an 18 inch Sun spot employing a faceted metal mirror and a 2000-watt G48 C13 Mazda globe is shown in Fig. 7 for angles of 14 (the narrowest divergence), 18, 24, and 30 degrees.
In the motion picture industry it is seldom necessary to project a spot beam narrower than 10 degrees, which provides a spot of light about eight feet in diameter at a distance of fifty feet. It is, however, desirable to be able to flood a lamp to a divergence as great as 40 degrees, provided that the projected beam at this wide angle is of sufficient intensity to be of at this wide angle is of sufficient intensity to be of photographic use.


FIG. 9. Intensity distribution of junior Solarspot;source: 120-volt, 2000-watt, G48 C13 bipost incandescent lamp.

For the conditions under which spot lamps are used, it is desirable that the beam have its highest intensity at the center and that the edges be soft so as to permit overlapping the beams of several such lamps without building up high intensities in the areas overlapped.
The MR Type 210 junior Solarspot lamp, illustrated in Fig. 8, is supplied with a lens of the type known as the concentric plano-convex Fresnel. A lens of this type can be made quite large in diameter, of short focal length, and of relatively thin section. This lens was designed particularly to fulfill the requirements of the junior Solarspot; and when used in combination with a 2000-watt G48 C13 Mazda globe will project a spot beam having a divergence of 8 degrees, and a flood beam of 44 degrees. The lens is manufactured of a superior, heat-resisting glass of high mechanical strength. Referring to Fig. 8, at the rear of the globe is provided a spherical mirror of the proper radius and aperture diameter, provided with two simple adjustments. This lamp utilizes a 2000-watt G48 C13 bipost Mazda globe. Such globes are, by their nature, virtually prefocusing; and when once the adjustments in the lamp are set, globes may be mounted or dismounted, and only slight readjustments of the spherical mirror are required to attain high efficiency of projection. The wide-aperture, short-focus lenses permit combined collection of the radiation from the globe and the spherical mirror within an angle of 74 degrees in the position for an 8-degree divergence, and of 104 degrees when the lamp is used in its maximum flood position for a divergence of 44 degrees. The short-focus Fresnel lens contributes to the over-all efficiency of the unit, but only careful attention to the design of the lens has made possible the excellent distribution provided by the equipment over a wide range of beam divergence.
Fig. 9 shows the angular distribution of the junior Solarspot for beam divergences of 8, 18, 24, 30, and 40 degrees. It will be noted that the wide range of distribution and the degree of intensity attained by this new equipment adapts it to a wide range of use in motion picture photography. For instance, with this lamp a person may be covered from head to foot at a distance of ten feet. A spot that can be flooded to this degree and to such an intensity makes a very useful lamp for general lighting. The fact that the projected spot at all times has soft diffusing edges permitting areas to be overlapped without showing rings or bands of lights, especially adapts it to back-lighting; and the wide range of intensity within the various beams is particularly advantageous for such purposes. Much experimentation has been done with an iris shutter applied to the lamp. By closing the iris and adjusting the focus of the lamp, a wide range of intensity may be attained for a given beam divergence for any type of photography demanding that the spectral composition be maintained constant, as for color photography. Control of intensity by an iris is most desirable, in avoiding the use of diffusing screens which have the characteristic of absorbing certain wavelengths and otherwise causing spectral imbalance.

 
 
*Presented at the spring, 1935, Meeting at Hollywood, California
**Mole-Richardson, Inc., Hollywood, California


Timeline
|SMPTE